Skip to navigation | Skip to main content | Skip to footer
Menu
Search the Staffnet siteSearch StaffNet

Research Ethics Myth-busting

Not sure what to expect from the research ethics review process? This guide addresses common misconceptions about UREC, what the review covers, and what is expected of applicants. It also highlights where to find support and guidance.

Do I need research ethics approval?

MYTH: “If my study is low risk, I do not need research ethics approval.”

Low risk does not automatically mean that ethical review is unnecessary. Use the Ethics Decision Tool to establish whether review is required and which route applies.

↗ Ethics Decision Tool

The UREC Route Assistant can help you decide which route is appropriate.

↗ UREC Route Assistant

MYTH: “If I'm only using existing data, ethical review isn't necessary.”

The need for ethical review depends on the data, its source, how it will be used, the permissions in place and applicable University and external requirements. Using existing data does not automatically exempt a project from review. The following guidance may be helpful depending on a study's data source.

↗ Guidance on the use of social media in research

↗ Guidance on the use of data archives

 

MYTH: “If my research does not need ethical review (e.g. is deemed ethically exempt), I do not need to think about ethics.”

Ethical reflection and consideration are required throughout the research process, even when formal ethical review and approval are not required. Researchers remain responsible for reflecting on the ethical implications of their work and conducting their research ethically and in accordance with relevant institutional guidance.

 

 

Understanding the UREC review process

MYTH: “UREC review is just a tick-box exercise. There are predetermined answers that applicants are expected to give.”

UREC review is not a tick-box exercise, nor is it intended to require applicants to provide standardised answers regardless of their research context. Preparing an application provides the opportunity to consider the ethical implications of a particular research project, reflect on potential challenges and demonstrate how these will be addressed. The application should therefore be viewed as an opportunity for considered reflection and appropriate scrutiny, rather than simply a mechanism for obtaining approval.

 

MYTH: “UREC doesn't review all year round.”

Full UREC (high-risk) committees meet from September to July. The committees do not review during August, allowing members to take a break and recognising that applicants and research teams may also have limited availability during this period.

Proportionate UREC (low- and medium-risk) review operates throughout the year.

 

MYTH: “UREC review causes delays to research.”

UREC timelines are not typically a cause of delay. Applications submitted within the published timeframes, of a good quality, and accompanied by prompt engagement with any requested revisions or feedback, including the submission of a revisions letter, are generally reviewed in a timely manner.

Average turnaround times for UREC applications are as follows*:

  • Full UREC (high risk): 10-12 working weeks
  • Proportionate UREC (low/medium risk): 6-8 working weeks

*Please note, shorter timeframes are possible where high-quality applications are initially submitted and prompt engagement with any required revisions is undertaken by the research team.

Where delays do occur, these are often associated with the time taken by applicants to respond to reviewer feedback and submit revised documentation. Researchers can help avoid unnecessary delays by allowing sufficient time for ethical review, ensuring applications are complete and clearly written, and responding to feedback promptly.

 

MYTH: “UREC feedback is overly critical or intended to make my application more complicated.”

UREC feedback is intended to help researchers identify and address ethical issues before their research begins. Reviewers may ask for clarification, request changes or highlight aspects of a study that require further consideration. This is not intended to create unnecessary work, but to ensure that the ethical implications of the research have been adequately considered and that appropriate safeguards are in place.

Feedback should be considered in the context of the proposed research and the University's responsibility to ensure that research involving human participants is conducted ethically and responsibly. Where applicants are unsure about feedback or disagree with a recommendation, they can seek clarification through the appropriate committee processes.

 

MYTH: “Professional Services staff don't understand research ethics.”

Professional Services staff have significant experience working with research ethics committees and understand the information required for all stages of ethical review. Their feedback at the screening stage helps ensure that applications are as complete as possible before submission to the committee.

Ethics expertise is not limited to colleagues in academic posts. Professional Services colleagues bring a range of valuable perspectives, including research experience, experience of supporting and overseeing research processes, and lived experience. This breadth of expertise contributes to the quality of ethical review and helps ensure that applications are considered from different perspectives.

 

 

Understanding UREC's role and remit

MYTH: “Ethics reviewers should not comment on my methodology.”

Methodology and ethics are often closely connected. UREC may comment on methodological aspects of a study where these have implications for its ethical acceptability, including participant burden, risk, informed consent, recruitment or the value and justification of the research. UREC may also ask for clarification where the methodology is not fully described.

 

MYTH: “UREC review is designed for biomedical research.”

UREC reviews research across a wide range of disciplines and methodologies. Its membership comprises academic and Professional Services staff from all three faculties, with representation across divisions and schools. This breadth of experience helps the committee consider research within different disciplinary contexts.

Reviewers recognise that research practices and ethical norms vary between disciplines. Applicants should explain their methodological approach and relevant disciplinary conventions, particularly where these may be unfamiliar outside their field. However, disciplinary norms do not remove the need to consider the ethical implications of a study, and reviewers may ask questions where further explanation or justification is needed.

 

MYTH: “UREC's role is to tell me how to address my ethical issues.”

Applicants are expected to undertake ethical reflection, identify the ethical issues associated with their project and explain how these will be addressed or mitigated where appropriate. UREC may ask questions about the proposed approach or highlight issues that the research team has not identified. However, it is the research team's responsibility to develop and justify appropriate responses and mitigations.

 

MYTH: “UREC does not support research collaborations.”

UREC reviews many applications involving collaborations with other UK and international academics, as well as external partners such as NHS organisations, charities, NGOs and industry partners.

Whether a study requires ethical review and approval from the University of Manchester depends on a number of factors, including where the Principal Investigator is based and where the research will take place. Researchers should consult the following guidance to establish which review arrangements apply to their project.

↗ University's Guidance on Collaborative Projects

In some circumstances, UoM may also accept or use ethical review documentation and templates from collaborating institutions, rather than requiring researchers to duplicate existing processes.

It is important to distinguish ethical review from contractual arrangements. UREC does not negotiate, review or approve research contracts, divisions of responsibility, collaboration agreements or funding agreements. These are managed through the University's Contracts Team.

↗ Contracts | Research and Business Engagement | StaffNet

 

MYTH: “UREC does not understand co-production or research involving people with lived experience.”

UREC recognises the value of co-production and research that meaningfully involves people with lived experience. Committee members have experience of undertaking and reviewing research using participatory and co-produced approaches.

Co-production does not automatically mean that ethical review is unnecessary. Equally, not every activity involving people with lived experience constitutes research requiring formal ethical approval. For example, the ethical review requirements will depend on the nature of the activity, the role of those involved and whether they are contributing as research partners or participating in the research itself.

Where people with lived experience are also involved as research participants, their involvement should be clearly described in the application, alongside appropriate consideration of consent, confidentiality, safeguarding and any other relevant ethical issues.

↗ Co-Produced Research and Community Engagement Ethical Review Guidelines

 

MYTH: “UREC reviews risk assessments and lone-working policies.”

Risk assessments and lone-working policies are compliance-related documents, and UREC no longer routinely requires copies to be appended to applications (unless the fieldwork destination requires approval by the Faculty Dean). However, reviewers may ask questions about risks that are not adequately addressed or are unclear in the application. Researchers remain responsible for following the relevant University procedures.

 

MYTH: “UREC favours vouchers over cash or other more appropriate local alternatives for participant payments.”

UREC does not favour one method of compensation over another. Reviewers may ask about the amount offered, how it has been determined and how participants will receive compensation, where these details are relevant to the ethical assessment.

The most appropriate approach will depend on the research context, participant group and practical arrangements. Researchers should also consider whether the proposed compensation method is appropriate and accessible for participants. University Finance requirements may also apply to the compensation method and arrangements.

↗ Spending Money | Directorate of Finance | StaffNet

 

MYTH: “UREC will stop me conducting research in 'red zone' countries.”

Decisions about whether University staff or students may travel to particular countries to undertake research activities are outside UREC's remit. The University's Risk and Compliance Team provides guidance on countries considered unsafe at particular times (please also refer to the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office's (FCDO) guidance).

Decisions about whether staff or students may travel sit with the relevant Faculty Dean. Applicants should follow the University's current travel risk and approval procedures.

↗ Insurance Office | StaffNet

↗ Compliance and Risk | StaffNet

↗ FCDO guidance

 

 

Participants, vulnerability and consent

MYTH: “If a participant is a professional, they cannot be vulnerable to pressure or distress.”

Being a professional does not mean that someone is immune to pressure, harm or other research-related risks. UREC expects applications to consider the specific context, including power imbalances, professional relationships, confidentiality and any potential consequences of participation. Participants may have standard distress protocols in place for the handling of such circumstances but the mere presence of these protocols does not negate the risk of them occurring.

 

MYTH: “UREC considers certain groups automatically vulnerable.”

Vulnerability should not be assumed solely on the basis of a person's characteristics or group membership. In some circumstances, an individual's ability to provide informed consent may be relevant; in others, the ethical considerations depend on the research context, the nature of participation and the potential risks. Applicants should explain the relevant considerations for their particular study rather than relying on assumptions about a group. UREC makes a judgement on the vulnerability of participant groups based on the context of the research itself.

↗ Guidance on Vulnerability (section 2.5 of the Digital Handbook).

 

MYTH: “All studies need to collect written consent.”

The appropriate approach to documenting informed consent depends on the research design, participants, context and relevant requirements. Written consent is not the only possible approach in every study. Where an alternative approach is proposed, applicants should explain how informed and voluntary participation will be established and documented.

↗ Guidance on Informed consent (section 3 of the Digital Handbook)

After approval: changes and incidents

MYTH: “Once my study is approved, I can make small changes without informing the ethics committee.”

Changes to recruitment, consent, methods, participant groups or data handling may affect the original ethical assessment and be subject to formal amendment.

↗ Information on amending an approved study

 

MYTH: “If something goes wrong, I only need to deal with it within my research team.”

Research incidents (including adverse events and deviations from approved methods) as well as potential breaches need to be reported to the REGIT team. Researchers should take appropriate immediate action to protect participants, document what happened and seek advice about reporting and next steps.

↗ Information on incident procedures

 

Completing your application and getting support

Myth - “There is no guidance on how to complete an ethics application via the Ethical Review Manager (ERM) system.”

Several sources of guidance are available to help you prepare your application and understand what UREC expects:

↗ Research ethics handbook: application preparation

↗ Research ethics training

↗ Training on the ERM system

↗ Research Ethics: clinics and further information

Applicants should use these resources when preparing their application and before submitting it for review.

 

Myth - “I cannot speak to anyone about my ethics application before submission.”

For students the first source of support is your supervisor. Those with a local review process, their School/Dept Chair should be another choice for support.

Details of those areas with a local process ↗ can be found here (sub menu at the bottom entitled Division/School Review).

Support is also available through the University's research ethics clinics. These provide an opportunity to seek guidance on issues related to research ethics and the application process which are not already covered by the existing wealth of guidance information available.

↗ Research Ethics: clinic appointments and further information