Message from the Chair of the Board
17 Nov 2026
Chair of the Board, Philippa Hird, reflects on the University’s progress, the President and Vice-Chancellor’s performance, and a new independent review of our governance
Last year, I shared the way in which the Board reviews the performance of the University’s leadership. As we complete that process for another year, I want to share our reflections on the progress made, the challenges ahead and the steps we are taking to ensure that the University’s governance remains strong, effective and open to improvement.
The President and Vice-Chancellor is accountable to the Board for the leadership and performance of the University. The Board has regular opportunities throughout the year to examine progress, test assumptions and challenge the University Executive on performance, risk and delivery. In addition, at the beginning of each year, the Board formally agrees clear objectives with Duncan and, at the end of the year, reviews his performance against them. Duncan and I have a performance review meeting which is then written up and shared with the Board for approval. For that review meeting we draw on agreed performance data such as Your Voice Matters, NSS, key league tables and financial metrics; Duncan’s own assessment; feedback from members of the Board; and the views of his colleagues in the University Executive. This year’s review showed consistent and sustained confidence in Duncan’s leadership. It also recognised that the University's ambitions are considerable and that delivery will not be easy.
Progress against From Manchester for the world
The Board noted that the successful launch of the new strategy was a major milestone for the University and had created real momentum. The focus over the past year has been on turning that strategy into a practical programme of delivery and agreeing the measures by which we can assess our progress.
Detailed delivery plans and an initial three-year work package are now in place or being rolled out. Executive committee structures have been aligned more closely with the strategy, and the frameworks through which priorities, resources and performance can be considered together have been strengthened. Feedback suggests that the strategy has achieved good visibility and a reasonable level of understanding across our community.
The Board is encouraged by this progress. We are under no illusion about the scale of what comes next and that delivery will involve making clear choices, aligning resources behind our priorities and ensuring that progress is sustained across a large and complex institution. We also welcome the steps being taken to strengthen the University's leadership, through work with the top 200 and wider development and training for leaders across the institution. This will help the organisation to rise to the challenge of delivering the Manchester 2035 strategy and create the necessary resilience. The strategic Leaps are underpinned by properly addressing important underlying needs, including our systems, infrastructure and student residences and we will be looking over the coming year to see evidence that the investment in our foundational infrastructure is improving the experience of both students and colleagues.
Teaching, research and the student experience
Improving the experience of our students remains an uncompromising priority for the Board and the Executive. The National Student Survey showed further progress, although our relative improvement was tempered by the sector raising its game in this area. Encouragingly, this progress is being reflected in improved domestic league-table performance and in a much stronger institutional focus on the quality of the student experience. There is more to do. Rankings and the NSS tell part of the story, but the real challenge is to build an environment in which consistently excellent teaching, support and student experience are understood as a responsibility shared across the University.
Our performance in global rankings has been more mixed. The University was ranked first in the Times Higher Education Impact Rankings, while our overall QS position fell to 40th and our position in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings declined slightly. Performance in some subject rankings improved, but citations, high-quality publications and reputational measures require sustained attention. The Board has engaged in immersive sessions on this topic and will continue to pay close attention to the interventions that are planned.
Innovation, infrastructure and institutional transformation
There has been progress across several of the major programmes supporting the strategy.
The first phase of Future Foundations has been implemented, an infrastructure investment plan is progressing well, and a more coherent model is emerging for connecting innovation activity across the University. There are also early signs of better-integrated support for industry funding, innovation partnerships and philanthropy.
Not every programme has progressed at the same pace. Manchester Online has not developed as fast as we had hoped and an approved business plan and delivery arrangements are now in place. Across all these areas, the Board’s focus is increasingly on delivery: whether programmes have clear outcomes, appropriate resources, realistic timescales and effective accountability.
Financial stewardship and philanthropy
The University’s financial performance has been strong, supported by robust planning, careful management of risk and cost, and a clear focus on the investment needed for the future.
At the same time, the environment facing universities remains challenging. Delivering the strategy will require disciplined choices and a clear connection between our strategic ambitions, our financial capacity and the benefits we expect each investment to deliver.
The Challenge Accepted campaign has also made an encouraging start. Fundraising has increased compared with previous years and the pipeline of potential support is strong. The task now is to turn that interest into long-term philanthropic partnerships and substantial gifts capable of supporting the University’s ambitions.
Leadership and external engagement
Duncan continues to lead the University with energy, commitment and a strong sense of its public purpose. Feedback from both the Board and the University Executive highlighted his ability to provide clear strategic direction, support colleagues to lead within their areas and step into difficult conversations when necessary.
He has also established the University as an influential contributor within Greater Manchester and nationally, building constructive relationships with civic leaders, policymakers, research funders, donors, industry partners and other universities. His visibility across our own community, and his willingness to listen to colleagues and students, remain important strengths. The Board has highlighted the importance of continuing to strengthen the profile and institutional leadership presence of colleagues across the University Executive, to complement Duncan’s highly effective approach in this area.
The review also noted that, notwithstanding progress made over the past 12 months in public affairs and stakeholder management, further work is required to embed a sustainable leadership model within Marketing and Communications, reflecting the importance of the function to reputation, student recruitment, philanthropy and our global positioning.
Reviewing the effectiveness of our governance
Accountability also applies to the Board itself. We should be prepared to examine our governance effectiveness with the same seriousness with which we review the performance of the University and its leadership.
As part of our regular cycle of governance reviews, we have commissioned KPMG to undertake an independent Governance Effectiveness Review. The review will examine how the Board, its committees, Senate and the University Executive work together, and whether our arrangements enable effective oversight, constructive challenge and timely decision-making. It will also consider the Board’s composition and skills, the quality of the information it receives, its oversight of strategy, financial sustainability, risk and academic governance, as well as the effectiveness of our engagement with stakeholders.
It will assess our arrangements against the updated Committee of University Chairs Code of Governance, the Office for Students’ Public Interest Governance Principles and other relevant guidance. It will also consider whether our Charter, Statutes, Ordinances and Regulations remain fit for the challenges ahead.
Good governance is about ensuring that important decisions are taken with the right evidence, that risks and competing perspectives are properly considered, that responsibilities are clear, and that the University remains focused on delivering its commitments. An effective Board should provide support where it is warranted, challenge where it is needed and maintain a clear line of accountability for performance.
As part of the review, KPMG will host stakeholder events to capture your views, and I encourage you to get involved. More information will be available on StaffNet shortly.
Looking ahead
The Board’s overall assessment is that the University has made substantial progress over the past year. We also recognise that the strategy deliberately sets a demanding course. The measure of success will be our ability to convert that ambition into sustained improvements for students, colleagues, partners and the communities we serve.
On behalf of the Board, I want to thank colleagues and students across the University for the expertise, energy and care they bring to our shared work, and Duncan and the University Executive for their leadership.
The Board will continue to support the University’s ambitions, challenge its leadership and maintain close oversight of delivery. Through the Governance Effectiveness Review, we will also ensure that we continue to strengthen our own contribution.
With best wishes,
Philippa Hird
Chair of the Board
